Can Ugly Design Work?

Posted on May 13th, 2006
By Todd Zeigler in Design, Politics

I came across the trippiest political campaign site I’ve ever seen today. Check out Eric Jon Gunderson for Congress (D-MT). We’ve got a litany of design offenses here: background music, spinning logos and clip art. We’ve also got some features that are just bizarre: an animated illustration of someone playing guitar in front of a tree and a section labeled fun that includes a typing test for reasons beyond me. The site is also missing the most basic of campaign site features. No donation form. No volunteer sign up.

As someone who works in web development, my first instinct was to pass judgment, write a snarky post and move on. But then I started thinking back to a Robert Scoble blog entry I read a few months ago about anti-marketing web design. To paraphrase, the theory is that sites like MySpace succeed in part because their designs are unprofessional - the lack of slickness makes them genuine and a true reflection of the site’s community of users.

Do I think the Gunderson site is successful? Nope. Would I advise a client to build a site like this? Absolutely not. But you know what, almost all campaign sites I’ve seen are devoid of personality, fun and humor. They are professional and cold and say very little about who the candidate actually is as a person. The Gunderson site most definitely has some personality. It is authentic, almost like a MySpace profile. There is a sweet spot between the heartless approach of most campaign sites and the homegrown style of the Gunderson site. That sweet spot is what I think campaigns should aim for.
Screen shot after the jump.

| Trackback URL |

Trackbacks/Pings

  1. Kinky for Friedman for Governor Website: Hitting All the Right Notes » The Bivings Report
  2. The Paradigm Shift

Comments

  1. Gunderson4Congress Staff

    There is a place to donate… if you so choose…. as to volunteering…. The average wage per year in Montana is $26,001 with many working more than 1 job. Who has time to volunteer? Who can afford to donate? If there are a record number of voters this year for the primaries, that will be one goal achieved! God bless and may you be at the polls!! All of us are running on empty this year, but Eric is running on MT looking for votes! Let’s do what right with what’s left….. Democracy works only when the people care! VOTE VOTE VOTE… and give your money to the local homeless shelter for feeding the hungry….. After the politicians get through with this country, someone else might be left to help the rest of us out with the basics. On the other hand, if the people stop voting for Politicians, maybe politics will improve. Eric isn’t a Politician, but he is a real Montanan whose Birthday was Saturday the 13th… so thank you for the review. They are fun to collect for a day when the future becomes history!!

about this blog

The Bivings Report (TBR) is a source of news, insight, research and analysis on the web-based communications industry. TBR content is posted, created and managed by internet strategists, media/communications analysts, web developers, designers and programmers, all of whom are employees of The Bivings Group.

Search Site

Archives

2009
Jan          
2008
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun
Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
2007
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun
Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
2006
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun
Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
2005
Jan Feb Apr May Jun Jul
Aug Sep Nov Dec    
2004
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun
Jul Aug Sep Nov Dec  
2003
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun
Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
2002
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun
Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
2001
          Dec

RSS feed RSS feed
RSS feed Facebook
RSS feed Follow on Twitter

Email Subscription


Delivered by FeedBurner

Collaborate

Send Tips Send Tips
Wiki Wiki

Authors

Tags

Most Popular Posts

Blogroll