Update: Are Ron Paul Supporters Gaming Digg?
Update: This article was submitted to Digg by someone I don’t know and was starting to gain a bit of traction (28 votes and 15 comments as of this writing). However, the story has been prematurely removed from the upcoming queue for the US Elections 2008 section. Digg has confirmed that the story was removed because it was buried. Why was it buried? I can think of two possible reasons: (1) the story was lame or (2) because Paul supporters didn’t like the content of the piece and buried it. Decide for yourself what happened.
Digg launched a section around a month ago on the 2008 US elections. I've been a semi-active participant in the section, digging stories in the upcoming area and occasionally submitting stuff there.
The strangest thing about the section is the prevalence of information about obscure Republican/Libertarian Presidential candidate Ron Paul.
A quick review of the Upcoming section shows that around 20% of articles are about Ron Paul. And just about every one of these Paul-oriented stories attracts at least ten diggs. This is extremely unusual, as the vast majority of stories submitted to Digg only attract between one and five diggs.
The trends hold when you look at stories that have made it to the section homepage (the most popular stories). In the history of the US Election 2008 section, only 21 stories have made the section homepage. Of those stories, 4 (19%) have been about Ron Paul. In fact, 4 of the last 10 stories to make the homepage of this section have been about Ron Paul.
It you look at it closely, it is clear that there is a group of Ron Paul supporters that is actively submitting stories to Digg and voting for every story about Ron Paul. As an example, users like MisesRothbard, EvilPropaganda, mstebbins, nokla and specsaregood seem to have Digg accounts primarily to promote Ron Paul. If you click through and look at their voting history, you'll see that those user names consistently vote for the same Paul-related stories.
It is clear to me that there is a semi-organized effort by Paul supporters to promote him on Digg. It wouldn't be the first time. According to the WSJ, Paul supporters were banned from the Pajama's Media Presidential straw poll after repeatedly trying to stuff the ballot.
At this point I think the gaming of the Digg US Election channel is working because the section isn't being used that heavily yet. The number of submissions is low and not that many people appear to be voting. So the Paul supporters are able to exert a disproportionate amount of influence. I think the content will get better as more people (and campaigns) participate. So start digging….
P.S. As a side note, check out this Paul article on Digg. I'd say its pretty obvious from the comments that Paul true-believers are dominating the discussion.
-
Cutkomp
-
Cutkomp
-
http://www.bivingsreport.com Todd Zeigler
-
http://www.bivingsreport.com Todd Zeigler
-
specsaregood
-
specsaregood
-
patr84
-
patr84
-
Cutkomp
-
Cutkomp
-
Cutkomp
-
Cutkomp
-
http://www.bivingsreport.com Todd Zeigler
-
http://www.bivingsreport.com Todd Zeigler
-
http://ronpaul.rescue-us.org Philly Dave
-
http://ronpaul.rescue-us.org Philly Dave
-
specsaregood
-
specsaregood
-
Tom
-
Tom
-
Mary Specht
-
Mary Specht
-
http://www.afterth.at Chris
-
http://www.afterth.at Chris
-
Midwife
-
Midwife
-
http://www.hammer2006.blogspot.com Alex Hammer
-
http://www.hammer2006.blogspot.com Alex Hammer
-
victor pillow
-
victor pillow
-
prattleon
-
prattleon
-
icanoop
-
icanoop
-
Ron
-
Ron
-
http://www.isupportthismessage.com Joem
-
http://www.isupportthismessage.com Joem
-
patr84
-
patr84
-
patr84
-
patr84
-
http://www.ronpaul2008.com Pat
-
http://www.ronpaul2008.com Pat
-
http://www.bivingsreport.com/2007/political-activists-and-social-networks/ Political Activists and Social Networks » The Bivings Report
-
blardy
-
blardy
-
Fafyrd
-
Fafyrd
-
http://www.bivingsreport.com/2007/should-candidates-use-social-networks/ Should Candidates Use Social Networks? » The Bivings Report
-
Dave
-
Dave
-
http://LiberatedSelf.com/ron-paul/ron-paul-poised-to-e2809csanjayae2809d-republican-primaries/8/ LiberatedSelf.com » Blog Archive » Ron Paul Poised to “Sanjaya” Republican Primaries
-
jp1
-
jp1
-
http://www.savegoogleanswers.com Gloria
-
http://www.savegoogleanswers.com Gloria
-
johnnyr
-
johnnyr
-
http://postpolitical.com/ppblog/2007/05/07/ron-paul-supporters-are-starting-to-creep-me-out/ postpolitical » Ron Paul supporters are starting to creep me out
-
Nick S.
-
Nick S.
-
basicspecifics
-
basicspecifics
-
Julia
-
Julia
-
http://www.bivingsreport.com/2007/you-cant-stop-ron-paul-you-can-only-hope-to-contain-him/ You Can’t Stop Ron Paul, You Can Only Hope to Contain Him » The Bivings Report
-
http://www.savegoogleanswers.com Gloria
-
http://www.savegoogleanswers.com Gloria
-
http://www.nickanstead.com/blog/?p=358 Nick Anstead » Blog Archive » Could Paul be the Dean of ‘08?
-
JesuBub
-
JesuBub
-
puma237
-
puma237
-
aisk
-
aisk
-
chris lawton
-
chris lawton
-
http://thunt.net thunt
-
http://thunt.net thunt
-
http://www.conflictingviews.com/t1523/#post25183 HAHA "Ron Paul Conspiracy" in straw poll – Conflicting Views
-
Matt
-
Matt
-
binaryloop
-
binaryloop
-
http://www.bivingsreport.com/2007/on-the-ron-paul-ban-at-redstate/ On the Ron Paul Ban at RedState » The Bivings Report
-
http://www.webpublishingblog.com/ron-paul-a-fraud-skeptics-need-to-wake-up.htm » Ron Paul a Fraud? Skeptics Need To Wake Up – Web Publishing Blog
-
http://danray.org/2007/11/05/ron-pauls-online-campaign/ Ron Paul’s online campaign — electric counterpoint — dan ray lives here



